Skip to content
Back to the journal

Music industry

Vinyl, CD and cassette: why physical formats still sell

Nobody needs a record to listen to music. That's exactly why records sell.

Oswaldo Gómez

6 min read

Spotify gives you the whole world's catalogue for less than the price of one album. And still, every Friday there are orders for coloured vinyl, signed CDs and short-run cassettes. I've spent years working with labels like Label 51 Recordings in Denver, and the conclusion is simple: fans don't buy audio. They buy proof that they were there.

Vinyl is an object, not a carrier

When we plan the first pressing of an LP, the question that matters most isn't the price. It's the colour. An opaque amber pressing or a clear splatter one sells out before the black one, even though they sound the same. The 12-inch artwork, a 180-gram pressing, the lyric insert and the hand-numbered copy do the rest.

On Bandcamp, a note like "first pressing limited to 100 copies" works very well. We used exactly that for the first vinyl run of a Matador LP at Label 51. It isn't a trick if it's true. Lie once, though, and your audience won't forget it for years.

The CD isn't dead, its audience changed

The CD lives in two places: on the merch table at shows, and with collectors of specific genres like prog, jazz or metal. A run of 500 costs a fraction of the same run on vinyl, a box of 50 fits in a backpack, and you can sign one in two seconds. For a touring band it's close to cash.

The cassette is identity

A cassette is rarely a business. It's a gesture. A run of 50 or 100 tapes for a very loyal scene in, say, lo-fi, punk or synthwave, usually with a digital download included, because plenty of people don't own a player anymore. If your audience belongs to that scene, go for it. If not, keep the money.

How not to end up with boxes in your lounge

  • Pre-order first, factory second. Open pre-orders for 3 or 4 weeks, measure demand, then place the order with real numbers. Your fans fund the pressing.
  • Short, numbered runs. Repressing because it sold out beats clearing stock at a discount.
  • Bandcamp as your main shop. The physical buyer is already there, and the fee on merch and physical sales is 10%, lower than the 15% on digital.
  • Thought-through offers. At Label 51, discounts go mainly to Bandcamp and the label's own site, never to the digital catalogue, which is already cheap.

What actually sells

I've seen releases with great campaigns that didn't shift a single record, and small editions that sold out in an afternoon because the band explained why that object existed. Physical works when there's a story behind it: a reissue that's been out of print for years, a colour that echoes the original sleeve, a run made for the fans who've always been there.

Streaming finds you listeners. A physical record tells you who your fans are.

If you're going physical, start there. Find out how many of your listeners would pay to hold something in their hands. That number, not your stream count, should decide the size of the run.